May 20, 2008
Entertainment

"Idol" finale: did Diebold rig it just for fun?


Alien vs. Predator.

UPDATE! In a shocking upset, David Cook won "American Idol" last night by 12 million votes. The soulful emo showboat snagged 56% of America's obsessive-compulsive texted votes, compared to virtuosic teen priss David Archuleta's 44%. On Tuesday'slast perofrmance showdown, the Davids, Season 7's crushingly obvious finalists, were tricked out in hokey boxing gear before they each their last three songs, and the judges had predicted a knockout for Archuleta, though puppetmaster/judge/scowlmeister Simon Cowell actually apologized to Cook Wednesday for underestimating him the night before. The Davids were the most evenly matched final two opponents in ages, making up for an excruciatingly dull competition overall.

The Davids' careful, media-savvy personalities have charmed the nation's already-overheated tweeners, but for the rest of us, there's something about the battle between the vaguely wooden, long-assumed champion Archuleta, and the rising star of his more genuinely charismatic upstart rival that's been feeling more than a little Democratic presidential nomination-ish. Just look at the outcome. Is David Archuleta the Hillary Clinton of "Idol"? And does that mean David Cook is the Barack Obama? The superdelegates are a non-issue on "Idol," but the similarities are way eerier than we could've ever guessed.

DAVID vs. DAVID = HILLARY vs. BARACK?

Why Cook's upset over Archuleta looks an awful lot like the Democrats' Final 2.

Coached by meddling family member Adorable family
Slightly robotic Smoother, flashier
Faux-humility Faux-edginess
Likely to garner the Latino voteLikely to garner the indie vote
Thought he had it in the bagMomentum has a life of its own
Soft yet somewhat masculine featuresDreamy, yet sorta goofy-looking
Popular with old ladies Popular with college students
Disturbingly experiencedYouthful vibe, but secretly grizzled

Posted by:
Right Now
Fourth of July Special: The Year in Grilling Americans agree: black folks know their barbecue McCain campaign taken over by...Steve...Who? The World's Worst PR Guy spins for Wesley Clark

Detroit Octane: "The Making of Obama-sistible"

Get a backstage pass to Detroit Octane's creative process.

More